ATS for Success:
Your Comprehensive Guide to Selecting an Applicant Tracking System

94% of staffing professionals say using an applicant tracking system (ATS) has positively impacted their business.

Are you ready to invest in the future of your staffing firm? Learn how to choose the best ATS for your business.

ATS ABCs

Get familiar with the what, how, and why of applicant tracking systems

What's an ATS?

An applicant tracking system automates a staffing agency’s recruiting operations and provides a central repository for candidate data, including resumés and applications.

They’re built to help you:

  • Manage every stage in the recruiting process, from application to hire
  • Manage candidate relationships
  • Reduce manual activities

Why do you need an ATS?

A good ATS has the power to turn your entire staffing operation into the most productive, profitable, and efficient business it can be.

The best applicant tracking systems:

  • Increase your recruiters’ productivity
  • Save time and resources
  • Provide organization and structure for your business

ATS Benefits: By the Numbers

 

Firms that use an ATS report:

  • 75% less wasted time
  • 70% faster report creation
  • 15% less time to fill
  • 10% more placements per month

Map Out Your Requirements

Follow these 5 steps to determine what you need in an ATS

how to choose an applicant tracking system

Review your recruiting process.

Document the steps in your recruiting workflow, making note of the activities a recruiter must do to perform their job effectively. Record any third-party tools (like job boards or social media) your recruiters use in the course of making a placement.

Use this process to understand where your firm excels and where an ATS can help you improve.

Make a wishlist.

What would your perfect ATS look like? What qualities of an ATS are most important to you? Which features are must-haves and which ones are just nice-to-haves?

Share your wishlist with prospective providers so they can address your specific needs.

Calculate your budget.

Create a budget for your ATS investment. Consider upfront setup fees and ongoing usage fees. Determine any additional budget you may need for additional integrations once you’ve implemented your ATS.

Use this budget to inform your ATS selection process. Ask providers upfront about any additional implementation or setup fees you may need to plan for.

Establish your time frame.

Determine when you need your new ATS to be fully functional.  Ask your providers how long implementation and training will take. Ask each provider about their onboarding resources. Do they offer training and support to get you started as soon as possible?

Create a timeline and schedule demos and follow-ups accordingly.

Determine what your current solution lacks.

What are your biggest pain points? What is costing you business or productivity? Where do your recruiters spend the most time? Are they doing too much manual work?

Make a list of the functions and features that will provide the most value to your business.

Do Your Research

Investigate what different providers offer and schedule demos with your top choices

Read about top ATS features to see which are most important for your business.

Top 5 Features

Use software review sites to find the ATS that matches your needs.


Top Peer Review sites

Narrow down your list of options to a shortlist of your top choices.

 

Learn more about these solutions by scheduling demos and discover which will best meet your needs.

Have at least one of your recruiters join each demo to get input from someone who will use the system every day.

 

After the demos, ask any additional questions you may have on key items, such as implementation, pricing, training, and onboarding your team.

Find Peer Reviews and Third-Party Advice

 
 
 

G2 Crowd features reviews for 300 applicant tracking systems—more than 10,000 authentic user reviews in total.

You can sort for recruiting software solutions by popularity, user satisfaction, and G2 Score—a combination of reviews and data aggregated from online sources and social networks.

Visit G2 Crowd

 
 
 

Capterra curates vetted reviews from real users. Capterra ranks ATS solutions by popularity, user-friendliness, and average rating.

You can also filter by features, such as onboarding, candidate tracking, and workflow management in order to find the software that meets your firm's specific needs.

Visit Capterra

5 Most Commonly Used ATS Features

The most important features, according to ATS users

Notes

Every interaction you have with a candidate counts, so everything should be in your ATS.

Add notes on a candidate record after an initial conversation or second interview to stay organized and keep your team up-to-date on the status of your candidates.

Tearsheets

Use tearsheets to organize your records into intuitive categories, such as “Top Sales Candidates” or “Available Engineers”.

Now when you have a job to fill, you can take action immediately.

Submission Lists

Submission lists provide your team with visibility into your submissions and open jobs.

Filter the list to quickly see relevant information like candidate status and job status.

Email Integration

With an email inbox gadget, you can see all the relevant information about your candidate in one place.

Add notes, parse resumes, or attach files without leaving your inbox.

Favorite Searches

You'll get familiar with the search function for any recruiting software you use, but you shouldn’t have to re-create your searches every time.

This feature prevents you from having to construct a new search every time you need to find out certain information.

5 Questions to Ask ATS Providers

What to ask before you select software for your business and why to ask it

1

Is your ATS built specifically for staffing firms?

Why ask it?
Staffing firms have unique demands. Solutions that aren’t built with staffing industry recruiters in mind may lack core functionalities.

2

Do you have an open ecosystem for partners and integrations?

Why ask it?

An ATS is not an island. If your ATS integrates with every tool you use, you’ll be more productive and effective.

3

Is your ATS mobile-friendly? Do you have a native mobile app?

Why ask it?

Recruiters like to work on-the-go. A native mobile app lets them be productive wherever they are.

4

Can you share case studies from successful customers?

Why ask it?

Case studies allow you to see if firms with similar use-cases were able to be successful with your ATS.

5

How long does it take to get recruiters up-to-speed?

Why ask it?

To get value out of your ATS, your recruiters need to know how to use it. Find out how long it takes to onboard your team and learn what training resources are available.

5 Questions to Ask ATS Providers

What (and why) to ask before you select software for your business

  1. Is your ATS built specifically for staffing firms?
    Why ask it? Staffing firms have unique demands. Solutions that aren’t built with staffing industry recruiters in mind may lack core functionalities.
  2. Do you have an open ecosystem for partners and integrations?
    Why ask it? An ATS is not an island. If your ATS integrates with every tool you use, you’ll be more productive and effective.
  3. Is your ATS mobile-friendly? Do you have a native mobile app?
    Why ask it? Recruiters like to work on-the-go. A native mobile app lets them be productive wherever they are.
  4. Can you share case studies from successful customers?
    Why ask it? Case studies allow you to see if firms with similar use-cases were able to be successful with your ATS.
  5. How long does it take to get recruiters up-to-speed?
    Why ask it? To get value out of your ATS, your recruiters need to know how to use it. Find out how long it takes to onboard your team and learn what training resources are available.

Further Learning

Invest Now, Save Later: Why a “Free ATS” Isn’t Always Free
ATS: Your Secret Weapon for Employee Onboarding
3 Essential Qualities of a Great ATS System
50+ Questions to Ask Your ATS Provider
How to Get the Most Out of Your Applicant Tracking System
[Checklist] 7 Ways to Identify Your ATS Needs

How Bullhorn's ATS Can Help You Be Successful

Increase Recruiter Productivity

Streamline daily tasks with faster source, search, and match

Improve the Candidate Experience

Leverage relationship insights to deliver a superior candidate experience

Make Better Business Decisions

Run your business by the numbers using staffing-specific, actionable reports

Take Advantage of the Powerful Bullhorn Ecosystem

Reach and Engage Candidates

 

Sense powers staffing firms to automate mass communication that starts one-on-one conversations. Teams send and receive messaging in Bullhorn to nurture candidates throughout their journey. Sense saves all communication in Bullhorn with real actionable insights. Sense users have seen NPS, referrals and redeployment double.

Learn More

 

TextUs helps your team get ahold of anyone, anywhere in real time. Recruiters can text or call from their computer, smartphone, or within Bullhorn, all while managing multiple conversations at once. Recruiters can also save and share templates, creating a uniform candidate outreach strategy with a 98% read rate and 40% response rate.

Learn More

Engage 2016 Sponsor Haley Marketing

 

Website development. Blogging & social media. Recruitment marketing. SEO & PPC. Content & inbound marketing.  Haley Marketing exclusively works with staffing and recruiting firms, helping them solve complex these complex marketing problems. 

Learn More

Increase Productivity, Visibility, and Working Capital

 

Recruiters and sales teams make hundreds of calls a week. How much wasted time occurs in between calls. Streamline critical communications directly within Bullhorn - Click to dial, power dialing from tear sheets, native pop-up notes, integrated IM & Texting, automatic call recording, and more.

Learn More

 

InsightSquared helps staffing executives break the cycle of spreadsheets by equipping them with actionable, real-time reporting on virtually all sales and recruiting KPIs. With this integration, you can improve pipeline visibility, better manager your reps, and ultimately forecast more accurately.

Learn More

 

Is your firm growing quickly? Whether you landed a big client or you’re opening a new office, there’s a good chance you’ll need additional working capital. BlueVine’s online platform makes it easy to get approved in as little as 24 hours with flexible options such as a line of credit or invoice factoring.

Learn More

Schedule a Demo

"We can’t imagine running our business without Bullhorn. We’ve seen our time-to-fill rate drop by over 40% since implementation.


Mark Eldridge  
ALKU Founder

Interested in growing your business with Bullhorn ATS?

Complete the form below to speak with our sales team.